Skip to main content
Figure 1 | EPJ Data Science

Figure 1

From: Complex network analysis of teaching practices

Figure 1

Comparison of Markov probabilities and colour map of correlations. In (a), the open circles are the prior probabilities P i (the probability of observing an active variable i at a given phase), the upwards pointing triangles are sustaining probabilities P( x i (t)=1| x i (t−1)=1) (the probability of observing an active i given that i is already active at a preceding phase), and the downwards pointing triangles are the first activation probabilities P( x i (t)=1| x i (t−1)=0) (the probability of observing an active i given that i inactive at a preceding phase). We ranked the variables in increasing order of prior probabilities. We see clearly that a vast majority of the sustaining probabilities are at least an order of magnitude larger than their corresponding prior probabilities. These variables have the tendency to self-sustain which suggests that we should treat multiple-phase activation of these variables as a single event. In (b) we compare the lag-1 sustaining probabilities against the probabilities P( x i (t)=1| x i (t−1)=1, x i (t−2)=0) and P( x i (t)=1| x i (t−1)=1, x i (t−2)=1) (i.e. treating variables as a lag-2 dynamical process). Unlike in (a), there is no clear increase in probability when the second preceding phase is accounted for. In (c) we show, on a colour map, the standard scores of observed conditional probabilities P observed ( x j (t)=1| x i (t−1)=1) against their expected values if i and j were independent. If i and j were independent and characterized solely by their respective prior probabilities P i and P j , the expected conditional probabilities should be equal to the prior, i.e. P expected ( x j (t)=1| x i (t−1)=1)= P j and the distribution of conditional probabilities should have a standard deviation of σ= P j ( 1 − P j ) / N i . The standard score is obtained from Z=( P observed ( x j (t)=1| x i (t−1)=1)− P j )/σ. The colours on the map range from blue (lower than expected) to teal (equals expectation), and finally maroon (higher than expected). The dominant feature of this map is a diagonal of higher-than-expected conditional probabilities for self-transitions.

Back to article page